Bollywood is no stranger to bold opinions. But sometimes, a statement lands harder than expected. Actor Prashant Narayanan has now stirred conversation across the industry after sharing his unfiltered views on Kartik Aaryan. Known for his intense screen presence in films like Murder 2 and Ghost, Prashant did not mince words while speaking about the Chandu Champion actor.
In a recent interaction, his remarks quickly caught attention. And they have since sparked debate among fans and industry observers alike.
Prashant Narayanan’s Blunt Take
During a conversation with Bollywood Bubble, Prashant Narayanan was asked about contemporary actors. When Kartik Aaryan’s name came up, he responded without hesitation. Prashant Narayanan said,
“I think he is one of the most terrible actors we have over here, but an extremely lucky person. He is only surviving because of his parents’ blessings. I feel that he is an extremely non-communicative and boosted by people around him kind of person. I liked him in the first film that he did (Pyaar Ka Punchnama).”
The statement was direct. And strong.
While Prashant Narayanan acknowledged that he appreciated Kartik’s performance in Pyaar Ka Punchnama, he made it clear that he has not been impressed with the actor’s later work.
His suggestion? Luck has played a significant role in Kartik’s rise in Bollywood.
‘Laughing With Somebody’ Vs ‘Laughing At Somebody’
The discussion did not stop there. When the host asked why audiences continue to support Kartik Aaryan’s films at the box office if his acting is questionable, Prashant offered another pointed response.
Prashant Narayanan said,
“I don’t know how many people are appreciating them, but I have seen people laughing at them. So, if you can make people laugh, that is a good enough thing. There is a difference between when you are laughing with somebody and when you are laughing at somebody. The Indian audiences are mostly laughing at somebody.”
This remark adds another layer to the debate. Prashant is not denying that Kartik’s films generate reactions. Instead, he is questioning the nature of that reaction. Are audiences celebrating the performance? Or are they simply amused by it?
It is a sharp distinction. And one that has triggered mixed reactions online.
A Career Built On Popularity
Kartik Aaryan began his Bollywood journey with Pyaar Ka Punchnama, a film that turned him into an overnight youth icon. His monologue in the film became widely discussed.
Over the years, Kartik carved a niche for himself in romantic comedies and commercial entertainers. He built a loyal fan base.
He was last seen in Tu Meri Main Tera Main Tera Tu Meri. The film, directed by Sameer Vidwans, was released on December 25 and featured Ananya Panday as the female lead.
Despite divided critical opinions on some of his projects, Kartik has consistently delivered box office numbers.
That consistency is often cited as proof of his bankability. But Prashant Narayanan’s recent comments question whether box office success directly reflects acting ability.
What’s Next For Kartik Aaryan?
Controversy aside, Kartik Aaryan’s slate remains packed. The actor will next be seen in Naagzilla. In the film, Kartik plays Preyamvadeshwar Pyare Chand, a shape-shifting naag. The project is directed by Mrighdeep Singh Lamba and written by Gautam Mehra. The movie is being backed by Dharma Productions and Mahaveer Jain Films.
This fantasy outing marks a departure from his usual romantic-comedy space.
In addition, Kartik also has a romantic film lined up with filmmaker Anurag Basu. The yet-to-be-titled project is the third installment in the popular Aashiqui franchise. Interestingly, the movie will also introduce Telugu actress Sreeleela to Bollywood.
These upcoming films indicate that Kartik continues to receive major banners and ambitious scripts.
Which makes Prashant’s remark about “luck” even more intriguing.
Industry Divides And Honest Opinions
Prashant Narayanan has always been known for speaking his mind.
Throughout his career, he has chosen intense, unconventional roles rather than mainstream commercial leads. His filmography reflects a performer focused on craft and character depth. His criticism may stem from that perspective.
At the same time, Bollywood operates on multiple metrics. Performance. Popularity. Marketability. Timing. Branding.
Sometimes, stardom is not defined by critical acclaim alone. It is shaped by public acceptance and commercial viability.
The debate here touches a larger question.
What makes a “good” actor in today’s film industry?
Is it awards?
Is it ticket sales?
Is it a range?
Or is it relatability?
Prashant clearly leans towards craft. But audiences may measure success differently.
Social Media Reactions
As expected, the remarks have divided social media users. Some support Prashant Narayanan’s honesty. They argue that actors should be evaluated more rigorously. Others believe the comments were unnecessarily harsh. They point out Kartik’s growth and box office numbers as evidence of his popularity. In the era of instant reactions, every strong opinion becomes amplified. What once might have stayed within industry circles now becomes headline news.
The Larger Conversation
This controversy is not just about two actors. It reflects the ongoing tension between commercial cinema and performance-driven cinema. Between star power and acting depth. Between audience expectations and industry standards. Kartik Aaryan represents a new generation of self-made stars who climbed the ladder without a film background.
Prashant Narayanan represents a category of performers who built careers through intense roles and character-driven storytelling. Both journeys are valid. But when opinions clash, the conversation becomes louder.
Final Thoughts
Prashant Narayanan’s comments about Kartik Aaryan are bold. Direct. And impossible to ignore. He praised Kartik in Pyaar Ka Punchnama. But he did not hold back while criticising his later work. Whether one agrees or disagrees, the remarks have sparked a broader debate about acting, stardom, and the criteria for success in Bollywood.
As Kartik continues to headline major projects, the numbers will speak for him at the box office. And as long as strong opinions exist, conversations like these will continue to shape the industry narrative. One thing is certain. Bollywood never runs short of drama. On-screen or off-screen.
Stay tuned with Cinetales for more deep dives into the latest movies, series, OTT drops, and box office battles — all in one place!
Follow Us: Facebook | Instagram | X |
Youtube | Pinterest | Google News |
Cinetales is on YouTube; click here to subscribe for the latest videos and updates.
